Affiliate disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links. Please see our Privacy Policy.

Chokecherry jelly is a wild foraged preserve you just can’t buy in the store. I make mine the old-fashioned way, with no boxed pectin and no mountain of sugar. What ends up in the jar is a tart, deep red jelly that tastes like the fruit itself.

Jars of homemade chokecherry jelly and jam with clusters of fresh chokecherries

Wild chokecherries grow in hedgerows, along woodland edges and in old fields across much of North America. The shrubs spread into thickets, so where you find one you’ll usually find plenty, and they’re easy to forage in great quantity.

Picked fully ripe, they have a bold, wild cherry flavor with a tart, puckery edge. That flavor is worth showing off, and a simple jelly is a lovely way to do it.

Save this article!
Get this sent to your inbox, plus get new articles from me every week via my newsletter!

That’s why I keep my chokecherry jelly simple. Most recipes start with a boatload of sugar, add plenty of commercial pectin and finish with a splash of chokecherry juice for color. If you’re going to the trouble of foraging chokecherries in the first place, you might as well savor their flavor rather than hide it.

A good harvest goes a long way, too. There’s chokecherry syrup for pancakes, chokecherry wine and the traditional dried chokecherry patties called legren. My list of chokecherry recipes has even more ideas for a big picking.

Notes from My Kitchen

Ashley Adamant

Since they’re a wild fruit, every chokecherry shrub is a little different, and they don’t all ripen the same way. Some of the plants we pick from ripen fully at bright red and are quite sweet. Others are still a bit astringent even when they’re fully black.

That’s part of the fun, learning the quirks of your own patches and making a one-of-a-kind jelly from them. You do have to be quick, though. Raccoons and bears tend to strip the shrubs the second the fruit is ripe, so I check back often to beat the wildlife to them.

Identifying Chokecherries

Chokecherries are generally simple to identify, since the fruit hangs in long clusters from distinctive shrubs. If you’re new to them, my chokecherry identification guide has the leaves, bark and flowers in detail.

Wild black cherry is their closest look-alike. The two are close relatives and look a lot alike.

A few things tell them apart. Black cherry leaves are narrower, with fine teeth that curve inward and a line of rusty fuzz along the midrib underneath. Black cherry fruit also keeps a small dried calyx at its base, and it usually ripens later in the season.

The fruit tastes different, too. Around here, black cherries are sweet but fairly bland, and they don’t make nearly as interesting a jelly. They’re a tasty edible, though, and actually a bit better out of hand than chokecherries.

Once you’ve narrowed it down to chokecherry or black cherry, a taste settles it. If they taste like cherries, that’s what you’ve got, and they’re best eaten fresh. If they give your tongue a thrill ride, they’re chokecherries, and they’ll make an epic jelly.

Common buckthorn is the one people actually pick by mistake, even though it isn’t a cherry at all. Its small black berries sit in tight clumps right along the stem, not on long hanging clusters, and each one has several seeds instead of a single pit. They’ll upset your stomach, so leave them be.

Invasive bush honeysuckles have bright red berries that grow in pairs where the leaves meet the stem, and they’re mildly toxic too. Pin cherries have bright red fruit in small bunches of four or five, but they’re an edible wild cherry.

Still, be sure you’ve positively identified the plant before you pick or taste anything. There are dozens more wild fruits worth looking for in my guide to edible wild berries.

Cluster of ripe black chokecherries, a chokecherry leaf and a single pit in an open hand
My hand holding a ripe chokecherry cluster, a leaf and a single pit.

Picking Chokecherries for Jelly

Once you’re sure you’ve found chokecherries, watch the clusters as they color up. They start out bright red and usually ripen to a deep red or near black.

For jelly, aim for mostly ripe fruit with about a quarter that’s slightly underripe. Less ripe chokecherries carry more pectin and more acid, and both help the jelly set. Very ripe or overripe fruit may not set at all without added pectin.

Taste a few of the darkest ones, too. Fully ripe chokecherries are actually reasonably sweet, and the astringent “choke” flavor all but disappears once they’re ready.

Jar of chokecherry jelly beside fresh chokecherries, and a spoonful lifted from an open jar

Ingredients for Chokecherry Jelly

This jelly doesn’t need boxed pectin or a pile of sugar. Ripe chokecherries bring their own pectin, and a modest amount of sugar lets their flavor come through.

Most recipes bury chokecherries in sugar, and I think the name might be why. Anything with “choke” in it seems like it must need burying in sugar to be palatable. Ripe chokecherries are sweet enough on their own, though, so the ingredient list stays short:

  • Chokecherry juice: From mostly ripe chokecherries with about a quarter slightly underripe, either steam juiced or simmered and strained. Wild fruit varies, so the amount of fruit it takes can vary too.
  • Sugar: Plain granulated sugar. I keep it low, so the jelly stays tart and the flavor stays concentrated. More sugar makes a sweeter jelly and a few more jars, with a milder chokecherry flavor.
  • Lemon juice: Fresh or bottled. I like a bit in my chokecherry jelly, since the acidity brightens the flavor and helps the natural pectin set, but it’s optional.

Chokecherries are naturally acidic, with a pH of 3.86 to 4.25 in a study of chokecherry cultivars grown in Saskatchewan. The tested chokecherry jellies from North Dakota State University Extension don’t add any lemon juice, so here it’s there for flavor.

That’s my first secret: half as much sugar as juice. I tested the yield on this recipe that way, and the amounts for a full batch are in the Yield Notes below.

White bowl of ripe dark chokecherries beside a fruiting sprig on a wooden table

Chokecherry Jelly Without Pectin

My second secret is skipping the commercial pectin. Chokecherries have a fair amount of natural pectin, but like any wild fruit, they vary quite a bit. Some batches, and some years’ fruit, just won’t set without pectin.

With patience, I can make jelly without added pectin from low-pectin fruits, like my raspberry jelly. If yours won’t gel, my chokecherry jelly with pectin is the dependable route.

After 15 to 20 minutes of cooking, the juice reduces enough to gel all on its own. The flavor ends up more concentrated than it would with boxed pectin, and the texture is smoother. Natural pectin makes a silkier spread than the powdered stuff.

Spoonful of chokecherry jelly lifted from the jar, showing its soft set without added pectin

The finished jelly comes out plenty sweet and really full of flavor.

Other wild fruits work the same way. My crabapple jelly sets without added pectin too, and so does my hawthorn jelly.

How to Make Chokecherry Jelly

Most of the work is in getting the juice. The jelly itself only takes 15 to 20 minutes at the stove once the juice is ready.

If you’re new to jelly making, my guide on how to make jam explains the basics. Jelly works the same way, just with strained juice instead of fruit.

Preparing the Chokecherries

Pick over the chokecherries and remove the stems, leaves and any other debris. Then give them a rinse in a colander.

Leave the pits whole. Chokecherry pits, leaves and stems all contain toxic compounds, and crushing or grinding the pits releases them. Cooking or steaming the whole fruit leaves the pits intact, and they strain out with the skins.

That’s also why I skip a regular juicer for chokecherries, since most of them crack the pits.

Extracting the Juice

I use a steam juicer, which is very efficient at extracting the juice. It takes about an hour to fully steam extract, but the yield tends to be better than other methods. It cooks and strains at the same time, too.

Without a steam juicer, put the stemmed chokecherries in a saucepan with a little water and bring them to a simmer. Cook them, stirring and mashing gently now and then, until they’ve released their juices, about 20 to 30 minutes.

Strain the mixture through a jelly bag or a colander lined with cheesecloth. Let it drip for at least 2 hours, or up to overnight, to get as much juice as you can.

For a clear jelly, don’t squeeze the bag. Just let it drip by gravity. If you’d rather have a higher yield, go ahead and squeeze out the last bits, and know that the jelly will be cloudy.

Quart jar of red chokecherry juice beside clusters of fresh chokecherries
A bit under 3 cups of chokecherry juice in this jar, straight from my steam juicer. I was able to draw off the full 4 cups for a batch by the end of a 60-minute steam process.

Measure the juice. Since chokecherries are a wild fruit, juice yields vary, so you may end up with a little more or less than a full batch. If you’re short, use half as much sugar as you have juice.

Cooking the Jelly

Pour the juice into a deep, heavy jam pot and stir in the sugar and the lemon juice, if you’re using it. Pick a pot big enough that it’s no more than half full, since jelly bubbles up a lot as it boils.

Bring it to a hard boil over medium-high heat. Stir often to prevent scorching and boil-overs, and keep it boiling until it reaches the gel stage, about 15 to 20 minutes. It can take longer on a smaller burner, so go by the gel test rather than the clock.

Spoon resting in an open jar of chokecherry jelly beside fresh chokecherries

Testing for Gel Stage

Without added pectin, the jelly only sets once enough water cooks off, so testing is how you know it’s done. Use either test, or both.

Freezer plate test: Put a small plate in the freezer before you start cooking. Drip a little hot jelly onto it, give it a minute, then push it with your finger. If it wrinkles, it’s ready.

Thermometer: Cook it until an instant-read thermometer shows 220 degrees F at sea level. At higher elevations, subtract 1 degree for every 500 feet. I’m at 1,000 feet, and my jellies finish at 218 degrees F.

If a batch doesn’t set, you can cook it again. The steps to fix jelly that didn’t set work for chokecherry jelly too.

Canning Chokecherry Jelly

You can easily make this a refrigerator or freezer jelly instead. Chokecherry jelly is also ideal for canning, though, and canned jars keep on the pantry shelf. If you’re new to canning, start with my beginner’s guide to water bath canning.

I get the canner going after I’ve extracted the juice, but before I start the jelly. That way it’s hot by the time the jelly is ready.

Ladle the hot jelly into hot, clean jars, leaving 1/4 inch headspace. Wipe the rims and put on two-part canning lids.

Set the jars in a water bath canner with the water at about 180 degrees F. Bring it to a full boil and process half pints for 10 minutes, adjusting for altitude (see the box below).

Turn off the heat, take the lid off the canner, and let the jars sit in the water for 5 minutes. That rest helps prevent siphoning when the hot jars come out.

Lift the jars out to cool on a towel on the counter, and leave them be for 24 hours before you check the seals.

Altitude Adjustments

Process half pints in a water bath canner for:

  • 0 to 6,000 feet: 10 minutes
  • Above 6,000 feet: 15 minutes
Sealed jar of homemade chokecherry jelly with a cluster of fresh chokecherries

Yield Notes

A batch starts with the juice from 5 to 6 pounds of chokecherries, about 4 cups. That’s with my steam juicer, and wild fruit varies, so you may need more.

I use 2 parts juice to 1 part sugar, so 4 cups of juice gets 2 cups of sugar, plus the juice of 1 lemon if you’re using it. That makes about 2 half pints of jelly. More sugar makes a few more jars.

Don’t double the batch. A bigger pot takes much longer to cook down and often won’t gel. Make two batches back to back instead.

Storing Chokecherry Jelly

Once the jars have cooled, press down on the middle of each lid. A lid that doesn’t flex has sealed. Put any jars that didn’t seal in the refrigerator and use them first.

Take off the bands before you store the jars, so a loose lid can’t hide under a ring.

  • Canned: Sealed jars keep in the pantry for 12 to 18 months. Store them somewhere cool and dark.
  • Refrigerated: Opened jars, and jars you didn’t can, keep for a few weeks in the fridge.
  • Frozen: Use straight-sided, freezer-safe jars with 1 inch headspace, so the jelly has room to expand. It keeps for up to a year.

Experimenting with Chokecherry Jam (or Fruit Butter)

After making chokecherry jelly, I started wondering if I could make a chokecherry jam instead. The pits do need to come out, but I hated the idea of composting so much of the fruit pulp along with them.

So I tried the technique I use for my cornelian cherry jam. Cornelian cherries also have large pits and are almost impossible to pit by hand.

Chokecherry jam in small quarter pint jars with fresh chokecherries and a leaf

I cooked the fruit the same way as for jelly. Then, instead of straining it all through a jelly bag, I used a spatula to press it through a fine mesh strainer.

Press gently, so the pits stay whole. As I worked the fruit against the mesh, most of the pulp went through, leaving just the pits and skins behind.

Chokecherry pits and skins left in a fine mesh strainer after pressing the pulp through

The result is somewhere between a chokecherry jam and a fruit butter. With all that pulp and its pectin still in there, it set up much faster. I barely had to bring it to a boil before it reached the gel stage.

Once it was in the jars, the chokecherry jam was almost like jello.

Spoonful of firm chokecherry jam holding its shape in front of the jar

It set very firm without added pectin, and I could scoop out whole spoonfuls that held their shape. Stirring it loosened it up and gave it a spreadable consistency.

It’s mostly smooth, but it has much more body than the jelly.

Open jar of stirred chokecherry jam with a spoon, beside fresh chokecherries

In the end, it was an interesting experiment, but the flavor is a lot better as a simple chokecherry jelly. I think the skins and pulp gave the jam a bit of bitterness. Not a lot, but enough to distract from the simple pleasure of it.

I’ll stick with chokecherry jelly, and the pulpy seeds from the jelly bag go on the compost pile.

Ways to Use Chokecherry Jelly

Chokecherry jelly is wonderful on hot biscuits or buttered toast, and it’s good stirred into plain yogurt or oatmeal. Its tart edge makes it a nice glaze for roast pork or venison, and it goes well with a sharp cheese on a cracker.

A jar also makes a lovely gift, since most people have never tasted it. For more ideas, here are 100+ ways to use up a jar of jam, and most of them work just as well with jelly.

Chokecherry Jelly FAQs

Wild fruit keeps things interesting, and these are the chokecherry jelly questions readers ask me most.

Can you make chokecherry jelly without pectin?

Yes, that’s how I make mine. Chokecherries have a fair amount of natural pectin, and a quarter slightly underripe fruit in the mix helps the set. Wild fruit varies, though, and some batches won’t set without pectin. Use the freezer plate test or a thermometer to tell when it’s ready.

Why didn’t my chokecherry jelly set?

Usually it came off the heat before it reached the gel stage, or it was a doubled batch. Very ripe or overripe fruit may not set without pectin, and wild chokecherries vary in pectin from batch to batch and year to year. A runny batch still makes a lovely chokecherry syrup, or you can cook it again.

Can I double this chokecherry jelly recipe?

I don’t. A bigger batch takes much longer to cook down and often won’t gel. Make two batches back to back instead.

How many chokecherries do I need for 4 cups of juice?

I get about 4 cups of juice from 5 to 6 pounds of chokecherries with my steam juicer. Wild fruit varies, though, and some readers have needed closer to 10 pounds for the same amount.

Do I need to remove the stems from chokecherries?

I do. Chokecherry leaves and stems carry the same toxic compounds as the pits, so I strip them off as I pick over the fruit before it goes in the pot.

More Ways to Use Chokecherries

There’s a lot more to do with a chokecherry harvest than one batch of jelly.

If you tried this Chokecherry Jelly recipe, or any other recipe on Practical Self Reliance, leave a ⭐ star rating and let me know what you think in the 📝 comments below!

And make sure you stay in touch with me by following on social media!

Jars of homemade chokecherry jelly and jam with clusters of fresh chokecherries
4.28 from 137 votes
Servings: 32 servings, makes about 2 half pints

Chokecherry Jelly (and Jam!)

This chokecherry jelly turns wild foraged fruit into a tart, deep red jelly without any boxed pectin. It takes just the juice, a little sugar and an optional squeeze of lemon.
Prep: 2 hours
Cook: 20 minutes
Canning Time: 10 minutes
Total: 2 hours 30 minutes
Save this recipe!
Get this sent to your inbox, plus get new articles from me every week via my newsletter!

Equipment

Ingredients 

  • 4 cups chokecherry juice, see notes
  • 2 cups sugar
  • 1 medium lemon, juiced, optional
  • 1 cup water, only if not using a steam juicer

Instructions 

  • Pick over the chokecherries and remove the stems, leaves and any debris, then rinse them in a colander. Leave the pits whole, since crushing them releases toxic compounds.
  • Extract the juice in a steam juicer for about an hour. Without a steam juicer, simmer the chokecherries with the water for 20 to 30 minutes, stirring and mashing gently now and then.
  • Strain the juice through a jelly bag for at least 2 hours, or up to overnight. Don’t squeeze the bag if you want a clear jelly.
  • Measure the juice into a deep, heavy jam pot, then stir in the sugar and the lemon juice, if using.
  • Bring it to a hard boil over medium-high heat, stirring often, and boil until it reaches the gel stage, about 15 to 20 minutes. Check with a chilled plate, or cook to 220 F at sea level, subtracting 1 degree for every 500 feet of elevation.
  • Ladle the hot jelly into hot, clean jars, leaving 1/4 inch headspace. Wipe the rims and put on the lids.
  • Set the jars in a water bath canner with the water at about 180 F. Bring it to a boil and process for 10 minutes, adjusting for altitude (see notes).
  • Turn off the heat, take the lid off the canner, and let the jars sit in the water for 5 minutes before lifting them out.
  • Cool the jars on a towel for 24 hours, then check the seals. Refrigerate any jars that didn’t seal.

Notes

Yield: I get about 4 cups of juice from 5 to 6 lbs of chokecherries in my steam juicer. Wild fruit varies, so you may need more. A batch makes about 2 half pints.
Fruit: Use mostly ripe chokecherries with about a quarter slightly underripe. Less ripe fruit has more pectin and acid, and very ripe fruit may not set without pectin.
Sugar: I use 2 parts juice to 1 part sugar, and I tested the yield that way. For a sweeter jelly you can use more sugar. It makes more jars and a less concentrated flavor.
Lemon juice: Fresh or bottled, for flavor. It’s optional.
Gel stage: Without added pectin, the jelly sets once enough water cooks off. Drip a little on a plate from the freezer, and if it wrinkles when you push it after a minute, it’s ready.
Batch size: Don’t double the recipe. A bigger pot takes much longer to cook down and often won’t gel, so make two batches back to back instead.
Chokecherry jam: Instead of straining the cooked fruit through a jelly bag, press it gently through a fine mesh strainer so the pits stay whole, and use the pulp in place of the juice. It sets much faster than the jelly.
Canning optional: Skip the canner and keep the jelly in the fridge for a few weeks, or freeze it in straight-sided freezer-safe jars with 1 inch headspace.
Altitude adjustments: Processing time for half pints in a water bath canner.
  • 0 to 6,000 feet: 10 minutes
  • Above 6,000 feet: 15 minutes
Storage: Sealed jars keep in the pantry for 12 to 18 months. Refrigerate after opening.

Nutrition

Serving: 1Tbsp, Calories: 64kcal, Carbohydrates: 16g, Protein: 0.1g, Fat: 0.04g, Sodium: 3mg, Potassium: 51mg, Sugar: 15g, Calcium: 3mg, Iron: 0.2mg

Nutrition information is automatically calculated, so should only be used as an approximation.

Like this? Leave a comment below!

Jelly Recipes

A few more jellies to put up from the garden and the wild.

Find the perfect recipe

Searching for something else? Enter keywords to find the perfect recipe!

How to Make Chokecherry Jelly pin with a bowl of chokecherries and a jar of jelly

About Ashley Adamant

I'm an off grid homesteader in rural Vermont and the author of Practical Self Reliance, a blog that helps people find practical ways to become more self reliant.

You May Also Like

4.28 from 137 votes (133 ratings without comment)

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

55 Comments

  1. Susan says:

    Hello – I am wondering if I were to combine juices from chokecherries and Concord grapes, will I need to add pectin or will the chokecherries have sufficient to make a gel? If it would work, what percentage of each juice would you recommend?
    Thanks

    1. Ashley Adamant says:

      Mixing them is fine safety-wise, since chokecherries and Concord grapes are both acidic enough for water bath canning. There’s no tested ratio for a no-pectin chokecherry and grape jelly though, and the set is the gamble. Chokecherries are only a moderate pectin fruit and wild ones vary a lot, so even straight chokecherry juice doesn’t always gel on its own.

      For the best shot at a good set, use powdered pectin. My chokecherry jelly with pectin (https://creativecanning.com/chokecherry-jelly/) and my grape jelly (https://practicalselfreliance.com/grape-jelly/) both use 4 cups juice, 4 cups sugar and 1 box of powdered pectin, so you can make up those 4 cups with whatever blend of the two juices you like. Happy canning!

  2. CHRIS SMITH says:

    5 stars
    Just finished my second batch…am so very happy that I found your recipe….for years I have struggled with jelly and syrup not turning outtheway I wanted but this recipe did notletme down…was worth the effort…I used 2 1/4 cups sugar and had to use bottled lemon juice…and it was a great success and the hubs loves it thanks and will try more of your recipes with raspberries etc thanks again

    1. Ashley Adamant says:

      Lovely! So glad you liked it!

  3. Deb M says:

    Can one extract the chokecherry juice with just a plain juicer then cook the juice/pulp?
    Please explain the method!
    I’ve got 6 pints of chokecherries-how much sugar for the jam?
    Water bath can?

    Appreciate any suggestions you have!!

    1. Ashley Adamant says:

      I’d skip the juicer. Chokecherry pits contain cyanogenic compounds that are released when they’re crushed or ground, and most juicers will crack them. Instead, simmer the stemmed chokecherries with a cup of water until they’ve released their juices, then press the cooked fruit through a fine-mesh strainer or food mill to separate the pulp from the pits (the jam variation is in the recipe notes).

      Measure the pulp and use the same ratio as the jelly: 2 cups of sugar per 4 cups of pulp for a tart jam, or up to 6 cups for a sweeter one. And yes, you can water bath can it with 1/4 inch headspace for 10 minutes (15 minutes above 6,000 feet). Fair warning, I found the jam a little bitter from the skins, so I usually stick with jelly. Happy canning!

  4. Dorcus Kleinschuster says:

    I was very happy to come across this method of making chokecherry jelly, and it works beautifully! Thank you!

    The 4 cups of chokecherry juice turned into 2 cups of jelly. Does adding commercial pectin give the end product a higher yield?

    I’m sticking with your recipe. It is absolutely delicious! Thanks for posting! 🙂

    1. Administrator says:

      The pectin does reduce the cooking time required so yes it will most likely produce a higher yield.